Islam Question and Answer - They differ concerning the timings of the prayer; who should they follow?

Sat 8/7/1434 - 18/5/2013

» Is there a specific age at which animals may be slaughtered?.

» He does not have any children and he wants to give his wealth to his wife and his brother’s daughter and donate the rest to charity.

» The wisdom behind the Prophet’s marrying more than four wives.

» Is it permissible to buy the house that was bequeathed to some of the heirs and not others without their consent?.

» Wife's Prayers When Visiting Husband Living in Another State.

» Imam and congregation offering du‘aa’ together following Jumu‘ah prayer.

» If he does ghusl following a wet dream, maniy continues to come out of him during the prayer.

» If the spouses were not praying at the time of the marriage contract, do they have to renew the marriage contract?.

» Her father did not allow her to marry a man, then she committed zina with him.

» Issues and rulings on kunyahs.

139757

Principles of Fiqh » Jurisprudence and Islamic Rulings » Acts of Worship » Prayer » Times of Prayers

They differ concerning the timings of the prayer; who should they follow?

ar - en

Share |

I am living in Holland and there are two mosques in the town where I am staying. Each mosque gives times for the call to prayer that are different from the other mosque, in addition to the timings that we find on the Internet. Which one should we follow? Please note that the difference between them is many minutes. The month of Ramadan is coming, in sha Allah, and the timings for Fajr and Maghrib prayer are different in each mosque. What do you think we should do? Which of them should we follow? Please note that one of the mosques is run by Turks and the other by North Africans. Or should I follow the timings on the Internet?.

Praise be to Allaah.

The timings for prayer are clearly explained in the Islamic texts, and they are based on things that are visible, and can be understood by any one with a little sense.

The time for Fajr begins with the breaking of the true dawn, in which the light spreads horizontally along the horizon, to the right and left.

The time for Zuhr begins when the sun moves from the middle of the sky.

The time for ‘Asr begins when the shadow of an object is equal in length to the object itself plus its shadow at the time when the sun is at its zenith.

The time for Maghrib begins when the disk of the sun disappears completely beneath the horizon.

Al-Nawawi said: What matters is when its disk disappears completely, and after it has disappeared completely the rays that remain do not matter; rather the time for the prayer begins even though those rays are still present. End quote. Al-Majmoo’, 4/169

Ibn Taymiyah said: At that time, the fasting person may break his fast and the time when prayer is disallowed ends, and what is left of red light on the horizon does not affect any ruling.

The time for ‘Isha’ begins when the red glow disappears from the horizon.

For more information on the timings of prayer, please see the answer to question number 9940.

You have to try hard to recognise the signs and act in accordance with them. If that is too difficult for you, then there is nothing wrong with following one of the mosques, if you trust the religious commitment and sincerity of the people in charge.

And Allah knows best.

Islam Q&A